نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Burial of the dead on private property is a manifestation of the conflict between individual property rights and public interest. In Imami jurisprudence, based on the rule of tsalit, the primary principle is based on the permissibility of the owner to occupy his property and bury there, and from an individual perspective, this act is considered to be free of religious prohibition. However, this permissibility is not absolute at the level of social jurisprudence, and in the event of harm to others, disruption of public health, disruption of social order, or material and moral damage, it is prohibited or restricted. In Iranian law, the principle of freedom of property possession is accepted based on Article 30 of the Civil Code, but this principle has been seriously limited by restrictions such as Article 132 of the Civil Code, as well as considerations related to public order and health. In legislative developments, especially the regulations approved in 1403, governing the burial of the dead, the dominant approach has shifted towards expediency and order. This approach has been more explicitly and structured in Iraqi law. However, one of the major challenges of Iraqi law is the lack of explicit and comprehensive enforcement guarantees regarding unauthorized burials on private properties, which has led to ambiguity in how to deal with this situation. A comparative study of the legal systems of Iran, Iraq, and even Egypt shows that despite the differences in jurisprudential foundations and the severity of regulations, a common trend can be observed in contemporary jurisprudential and legal systems, which is the move from “applying the right of ownership” to “restricting it by public interest.” In all of these systems, the burial of the dead on private properties is no longer considered an absolute right, but is influenced by considerations of health, public order, human dignity, and urban management. The main difference between the systems is the degree of rigor, legislative transparency, and the way in which enforcement guarantees are foreseen; In a way, Egyptian laws are at the top of the strictest, Iraqi laws are in the middle with legislative gaps, and Iranian laws are in the flexible but non-transparent state.
کلیدواژهها English